You did what in Scala?

Posted on by

This morning when I got into work, the first thing that anyone said to me was “you did what in Scala?”  Not the usual greeting I get in the morning… clearly I had stirred something up.  I knew exactly what this person was talking about, the evening before I committed some code, and then tweeted this:

Just added scala for the first time to an existing Java project. Not too shaby.

As soon as I saw the build passed on our CI server, I went home, but it caught the attention of my product manager, and he was very intrigued.  What I had in fact done was started writing unit tests for an existing Java service that I was working on in Scala.  Why did I do this?  A number of reasons:

  1. I’ve been meaning to learn Scala for at least a year.
  2. I’ve seen Scala unit tests before, and they look very cool, they’re very good at minimising boilerplate, and very easy to read and understand.
  3. At VZ, we are free to make sensible technology choices.  This ranges from what libraries we use, to what databases we use, to what languages we use.  Nothing is off limits, as long as we can provide a good argument as to why it’s better than the alternatives.  And when we do that, our managers trust us.

My product manager of course had no problems with me using Scala, we have another project here that uses Scala and he thought I meant I had done some work on that, and was interested in knowing why.  After explaining that I had actually added Scala to the project I was supposed to be working on, he was completely fine, and that’s one of the things I love about working for VZ, we have the freedom to make our own decisions.

For those that are not familiar with Scala, here is a quick overview of how I introduced Scala into my existing Java project.

First, I did my research.  What unit testing frameworks are there in Scala?  You’ll quickly find that there are two popular frameworks, one called specs, and another called ScalaTest.  ScalaTest supports a number of different testing styles, including TDD and BDD, while specs only supports BDD.  I only wanted BDD, so both were equal to me at this point.  Further research showed that specs has good integration with my favourite mocking framework, Mockito, so I went with specs.  I suggest you do your own research for your own purposes, my comparison here is far from complete.

Next, since I’m using Maven, I needed to add Scala to my maven project.  I found a blog post that explained how to add Scala to a maven project in 4 steps, and I was able to build my project in no time.  I also added a dependency on the specs library, and configured the Maven surefire plugin to run any classes ending in Test or Spec, as per the instructions for integrating with Maven and JUnit in the specs documentation.  I use IntelliJ IDEA as my IDE, so I searched for a Scala plugin in my preferences, found one, installed it, and after a restart IDEA had Scala support.  The IDEA instructions say that you need to install the Scala SDK, but since I was using Maven, I could just add the scala compiler as a provided maven dependency, then go to the Scala compiler preferences and point IDEA at that dependency.

Finally I had to write my tests.  Below is the first test that I wrote.  If you’re a Scala guru, I’m sure you’ll see things that I could have done simpler or that I haven’t followed conventions for, so I’m happy for you point them out to me, I’m still learning.

class WorkResultHandlerSpec extends SpecificationWithJUnit with Mockito {
  "Work result handler" should {
    val tracker = mock[WorkResultTracker]
    val handlerChain = mock[HandlerChain]
    val workUnit = WorkUnit.builder(JobType.TEST_MESSAGE, null).build
    val job = Job.builder(JobType.TEST_MESSAGE).build
    var handler = new WorkResultHandler(tracker)

    "call handler chain only once" in {
      handler.handle(job, workUnit, handlerChain)
      there was one(handlerChain).passToNextHandler(job, workUnit)

    "pass the result to the tracker" in {
      val workResult = WorkResult.success
      handlerChain.passToNextHandler(job, workUnit) returns workResult
      handler.handle(job, workUnit, handlerChain)
      there was one(tracker).trackWorkResult(JobType.TEST_MESSAGE, workResult)

    "return the result" in {
      val workResult = WorkResult.success
      handlerChain.passToNextHandler(job, workUnit) returns workResult
      handler.handle(job, workUnit, handlerChain) mustEq workResult

    "track an exception as a failure" in {
      handlerChain.passToNextHandler(job, workUnit) throws new RuntimeException("Something bad happened")
      val workResult = handler.handle(job, workUnit, handlerChain)
      workResult.getStatus.isSuccess must_== false
      workResult.getMessage mustEq "Something bad happened"
      there was one(tracker).trackWorkResult(JobType.TEST_MESSAGE, workResult)

6 thoughts on “You did what in Scala?

  1. sounds really cool james :) i was always asking miself why the scala guys needed to invent SBT instead of using Maven.

    well done ;)

  2. Hi James,

    It’s good to know that you selected specs for your project but I strongly encourage you to pick up specs2 instead (, because this is the project that’s evolving forward.

    Just contact me on twitter @etorreborre if you have any issue with the migration.


  3. Getting a personalized pick from a custom shop is not only difficult but is also very expensive, hence a normal personalized
    pick that is not true at all. But Summit says 3-D printing an acoustic guitar cases at walmart, get help from a friend who knows
    guitar cases at walmarts inside out.

  4. Baschera disse:Ainda não me convencí das maravilhas das aeronaves de 5G e seus preços estratosféricos.Porém acredito que a diferença se fará por outras coisas, como os sensores e armamentos modernos. Uma plataforma 4G munida de sensores, armas e demais complementos em estado da arte e pilotos realmente bem treinados, perde pouco para um 5G.Combates de simulação virtual não valem.Investe-se agora em radares e sistemas de alerta capazes de complicar as tecnologias stealth. Acho que é por aí……Sds.

  5. i decided a while ago to let june grow hers out with donation as a goal. it's great that you are donating your fabulous hair. can't wait to see the new do.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *